May 21, 2004

New York Times' Gaffe

I'm really surprised to see that translated subtitles of people's short interview clips used in Nicholas Kristof's Multimedia report from Iran, Six Questions For Iran do not match what they really say.

For instance, the young farmer in the second part of the first question, talks about someone who has been thrown out of the parliament because of his or her constant criticism, but the English subtitles are about the chance of Shah's son to return and how things were better in Shah's time, which is also mentioned by Mr. Kristof himself.

I'm not trying to say that what Kristof or the subtitles say are not truth and the young man has never said these. But I guess the Iranian editor or assistant who has selected the clips hasn't been accurate enough.

Unfortunately the young farmer's clip is not the only example of such problem.

Posted by hoder at May 21, 2004 1:43 AM

Comments
Wrong subtitles are often used in European comedy shows on TV... someone is interviewed in a foreign language and the subtitles are completely wrong. Perhaps the translator was trying to be funny..? But seriously, this mistranslation thing (intentional or not) is very bad. I'm grateful it was pointed out. It's a scary thought that a journalist with an agenda can twist the meaning of a person's words, and bring home a false message.
- By: A.R. Yngve on May 22, 2004
---------
Yeah, I think from the whole thing, maybe there were only two or three instances where the subtitles actually matched what was being spoken! I hope his translator didn't fabricate stuff just to please him.
- By: s. on May 22, 2004
---------
I was thinking about exactly the same thing when I was watching it, the subtitles were TOTALLY off ...
- By: legofish on May 21, 2004
---------
Post a comment
bold (ctrl-shft-B)italics (ctrl-shft-T)link (ctrl-shft-A)
Name*:   
Email*:
URL:


Note:
* Required
The following HTML tags are allowed in your comments: <a> <b> <i>. To make line and paragraph breaks, press return (don't use <br> or <p>).
The bold, italics, and link buttons (and associated shortcut keys) only work in IE 5+ on the PC.