October 27, 2005

The fundamentalist minority

I'm very sorry about what this fundamentalist moron who happens to be Iran's president has recently said. But I have to say he doesn't represent the way the majority in Iran think. This guy is a fraud and is a puppet of Mesbah-e Yazdi, a radical cleric who is only gaining power after Khomeini's death.

Ahmadinejad only represents a small number of radical clerics around Mesbah and some Revolutionary Guards commanders who benefit from violence and war. Ahmadinejad is an indirect result of America's policy shift against the reformists in Iran. Maybe they wanted this in the first place? Who knows.
However, the best indicator for me about the general attitude of Iranians towards Israel happened last year during the Olympic games when the Iranian Judoka refused to face his Israeli counterpart and eventually lost a medal. Average Iranians were quite angry about that and even in a poll I put on my Persian blog, the majority disagreed with the official policy of the Iranian regime.

Also, in a region where US is usually seen as the closest ally of Israel, Iranians has one the most positive attitudes towards the United States which is very likely to extend to Israel, despite all the government's propaganda.

Meanwhile, one neglected aspect of Ahmadinejad's comments could be a reaction to Supreme Leader Khamanei who has effectively kept the area of foreign policy totally out of Ahmadinejad's control, by appointing Ali Larijani, his trusted young ally, to be leading the nuclear negotiation team.

Interestingly, the current Foreign Minister, Manoochehr Mottaki, has been an old assistant to Larijani and this shows how influential Khamanei is. So this could be a challenge by Mesbah and his allies, including Ahmadinejad, to Khamanei's control on foreign policy.

Posted by hoder at October 27, 2005 4:42 AM

Comments
I just have one question and I dare any persian Muslim to answer it when was the last time Israel or Jews did anything against Iran. The only force that is destructing iran is Hezbollah. Any openminded Iranian knows this. and Mr. Ali I have a question for you. Can you get up from your computer bring a Quran put your hand on it and swear that you love Iran? I respect Quran as a holy book and I am sure you will not swear because you do not love Iran. If you did you would worry about Iran instead of spreading hate to the countries that have nothing to do with you. forever Iran forever Israel forever Palestine shame on terririst and Hezbollah
- By: yazdy on November 5, 2005
---------
I love Israel and I love Iran. If you hate the jews or hate israel G-d will hate you.
- By: Irani on November 5, 2005
---------
This is hypocrisy, which displays the sheer disparity of power in international affairs. Iran should have nothing to apologize for. In the words of Prof AbuKhalil: "Let me get this straight. The Security Council met in a special session yesterday and issued a strong condemnation of the words of the Iranian president. In the same week, Israeli occupation forces, using fighter jets, launched more than 13 raids into Gaza, the most densely populated area of the world, and the Security Council did not even notice? Where is the outrage, as Bob Dole used to say . . . So France summoned Iranian ambassador over remark about the destruction of Israel. Will France summon Israeli ambassador over the actual destruction of Palestine by Israel?
- By: Ali on October 31, 2005
---------
I'm always amazed by the Iranian proclivity to blame actions on the West for what happens in Iran politically. "If Bush wasn't such a bully, Ahmadinezhad wouldn't have been elected." "If the Brits didn't support the Mullahs, they wouldn't be in power." "If Carter hadn't turned his back on the Shah, the Revolution would not have happened." How about: "When the Iranian poeple get fed up with the Mullahs, they will kick them out?" The West can put all their weight against the Regime in Tehran, but until the Iranian people take to the streets, nothing is going to change there.
- By: Kevin in Dallas on October 29, 2005
---------
It was the same so-called Iranian intellectual elites, aka leftist liberals, aka today's "reformers," who brought us khomeini, and the same "reformers" who kept akhoundism in place for 26 years by selling the mirage of possibilities of "working the system from within," and its the same damned "reformers" who still refuse to accept that they've been a big part of the problem, that they've been the major enablers of akhoundism. "Reformers" still make excuses instead of facing what Iran has become after quarter of a century of akhoundism: a basket case.
- By: parisa on October 28, 2005
---------
The following are excerpts from a speech by Iranian Leader 'Ali Khamenei, aired by Channel 1, Iranian TV on May 9, 2005. 'Ali Khamenei: The experience of the West, in short, is unsuccessful. The West's experience in forming social regimes has produced Fascism, in the form of the Nazi regime, Communism, in the form of the Soviet block regimes, and liberalism, which is the unrestrained regime of today's world. Liberalism is manifest in America, and the apple of its eye is Israel. All the crimes committed over the past 150 years, since Western enlightenment… All the crimes committed during this era are a product of the Western experience. Perhaps the crematoria that the Jews claim (existed) are a lie, but Hitler's crimes are no lies. Fascism is one example of the Western experience. - Can somebody with expertice on Iranian politics tell a novice like myself just exactly how much Khameneis views have popular support, and in what sections of the population?
- By: Jaakko on October 28, 2005
---------
"Ahmadinejad is an indirect result of America's policy shift against the reformists in Iran" = NOT. Az Mast ke Bar Mast = Man hargez az biganegan nanalam/un che kard ba man ashna kard = You can't pin Ahmadinejad on the US government. The US government never had a "policy shift" against (or towards) the reformists in Iran - The US policy is in relation to the Iranian Government, not its various factions. It is time Iranians stop blaming the outside world for the damage it inflicts on itself (see: "Ma Cheguneh Ma Shodim")
- By: Bahman Azimi on October 28, 2005
---------
As an Iranian, I can not beleive you and actually is a funny think about Iranians. Look at the street of Iran today, Qods day. Are the people in the streets are agree with Israel? You can say this to the people who do not know anything about Iran, but the truth does not change. I do not know what is your benefit of writing these funny things and what mad man can beleive this. Hossein, people has eyes and see the things!!!! Stop to asuming the people mad!!!
- By: Mohammad on October 28, 2005
---------
Ahmadinejad? someone had to 'vote' for him. He has to enjoy some amount of support in Iran or all hell would break lose. Or at least it should. Many in the US think that Iran's govt is crazy. So if Tehran said that they were going "to build a city on the moon", many in the US would just nod and smile. A polite smile. Tehran has said a lot of 'stupid' and 'silly' things. American's wonder, "does the average Iranian believe this nonsense"?? (out of Tehran)
- By: jgonzz on October 28, 2005
---------
"Ahmadinejad is an indirect result of America's policy shift against the reformists in Iran" ?? In vasleh ha be ma nemichasbeh - "az mast ke bar mast" - "Man hargez az biganegan nanalam/un che kard ba man ashna kard" - First of all, there was never any "policy shift" either for or against the reformists: the US government's policy is towards the Iranian government as a whole, not various factions. Secondly, Iran as a country and a people needs to accept responsibility for its actions and for its past. The US and Brits didn't bring about the Revolution: Iranians did. And the US was not responsible for this moron: the Iranians picked him.
- By: Bahman Azimi on October 27, 2005
---------
To Steven Reeves: The article states, "America's policy shift AGAINST the reformists in Iran." Not "towards".
- By: Bahram on October 27, 2005
---------
Ahmedinejad's comments should have suprised nobody, since they reflect the policy of the Iranian government. What would be the purpose of holding a "World Without Zionism" conference if not to destroy Israel? Some apologists for the Iranian regime were unhappy with Ahmedinejad because he spoke the truth. That is embarrassing to them, because they don't want to be openly associated with people who advocate genocide. It is not nice. Of course, Ahmdinejad's remarks do not reflect on the desires or will of the Iranian people necessarily. The whole idea of a non-democratic government is that it is not democratic. Still, people voted for him - the same people whom you say are pro USA and possibly not too anti-Israel. See Iran wants to destroy Israel - so what else is new? for a bit more about this
- By: Ami Isseroff on October 27, 2005
---------
your statement that the Mesbah guy has gained power only after the death of Khomeini is like you want to adjust the words about Israel been his. It is a fact though, that Ahmadinezhad did cite Khomeini in this affair and Khomeini was not better in respecting international norms in this issue. so it is not only a problem of radicals rather a problem of the islamic system of government.
- By: Babak on October 27, 2005
---------
I like the guy and we elected, so he is what majority of Iranians want.
- By: ali on October 27, 2005
---------
"Policy shift towards the reformers in Iran", who else they going to "shift their policy to" I suppose in this case the U.S. cannot win, support the reformers and they bring the hardliners to power, support the hardliners and they are hurting the reformers. No wonder we in the west are confused.
- By: Stephen Reeves on October 27, 2005
---------
Post a comment
bold (ctrl-shft-B)italics (ctrl-shft-T)link (ctrl-shft-A)
Name*:   
Email*:
URL:


Note:
* Required
The following HTML tags are allowed in your comments: <a> <b> <i>. To make line and paragraph breaks, press return (don't use <br> or <p>).
The bold, italics, and link buttons (and associated shortcut keys) only work in IE 5+ on the PC.